So, I’m making a nifty DVD for some friends, using iMovie and iDVD, on my iMac. At first things go great. I easily import the DV from my camera. I spend a couple of hours cleaning up the video, adding some fades in and out, and generally making it look nice. Then I export it to iDVD, which takes forever, and crashes every time the iMac decides to go to sleep.
Finally I get it exported, and run iDVD. Turns out the video needs to be under 90 minutes – I’ve got about 92 minutes. Back to iMovie, and painfully cut a few seconds here and there to try to make it fit without ruining the performance. I get it to 89 minutes and 58 seconds, and re-export, leaving it to run overnight.
In iDVD, I discover that the menus and other things actually take up video time, even when turning the video menus and motion off. iDVD tells me my DVD is 90 mins and 1 second – painful! I go back and find a few more seconds to cut, and re-export, yet again. This time it finally works.
I burn a DVD, and pop it into my DVD player in my home entertainment system. Eureka, it works! Only one problem – towards the end, the sound gets way out of sync. Like nearly a full second early, by the end.
After some sleuthing on the web, I find there’s a way to fix this using Quicktime Pro, but I don’t really want to buy more software to fix what seems to me to be a bug in iMovie. However, I also find that I’m using iMovie 2, and there’s a free upgrade to iMovie 3 – maybe that will do it? So, I use the handy-dandy OS X Software Updater to get the new iMovie.
iMovie 3 runs great, and looks great, and even supports chapter markers, so I spend some time putting them in. Then I click Export, and I find that it doesn’t work with iDVD 2 – bummer! I can’t even download iDVD 3, even if I wanted to pay the $49 for it – I have to order the iLife CD, and wait for it to arrive. How frustrating.
Now I’m exporting to iDVD 2 from iMovie 3, having finally found the technical bulletin that tells me what settings to use. And it looks like I’ll still have to buy Quicktime Pro to fix the damn sound sync problem. Isn’t that just a bug in iMovie?
Apple has gotten a lot of things right, and iMovie and iDVD in general are wonderful and easy to use programs. But they’re so close to perfect, that these bugs are incredibly annoying.